Home LifestyleTobacco Bill Debate: BAHLITA Pushes for Stakeholder Inclusion

Tobacco Bill Debate: BAHLITA Pushes for Stakeholder Inclusion

by Naomi Wanjiru
3 minutes read
Tobacco Bill Debate: BAHLITA Pushes for Stakeholder Inclusion

The Bar Hotels and Liquor Traders Association of Kenya has raised the alarm over what it describes as attempts to sideline key stakeholders from the public participation process on the Tobacco Control Amendment Bill, 2024, framing the issue as one that goes far beyond tobacco regulation and strikes at the core of Kenya’s constitution.

Speaking on behalf of BAHLITA, which represents more than 54,000 traders across all 47 counties, the association argued that the Constitution of Kenya 2010 was built on a promise of openness, accountability and public participation, and that Parliament was never meant to legislate in isolation. As the Bill moves from the Senate to the National Assembly, BAHLITA says it has become aware of efforts by certain interests to keep affected stakeholders out of the conversation, a move it calls a direct threat to constitutional rights rather than a procedural technicality.

BAHLITA was direct in stating that public participation is not something to be granted at the discretion of lawmakers. It is a constitutional right, and excluding stakeholders who will be directly affected by the Bill risks producing legislation disconnected from realities on the ground.

The association was careful to draw a line between opposing the Bill’s public health goals and opposing its current regulatory approach. BAHLITA said it supports efforts to prevent youth access to tobacco products and backs stronger enforcement against illegal and noncompliant operators. Its objection is not to the Bill’s intent, but to a framework it believes would create duplication, raise compliance costs and ultimately weaken enforcement rather than strengthen it.

Four specific concerns anchored the association’s position. First, BAHLITA warned that the proposed licensing and registration framework risks layering new requirements on top of businesses already operating under existing national and county regulatory systems. More licenses, the association argued, do not automatically mean more compliance, they often just mean more bureaucracy.

Second, BAHLITA said the Bill does not adequately account for the realities facing micro, small and medium enterprises. Most retailers in this space are small operators, and every additional license, fee or approval process adds to the cost of doing business, pushing some operators toward informality rather than compliance.

Third, the association called for a coordinated, integrated regulatory framework between national and county governments, pointing to the need for shared databases, mutual recognition of licenses, seamless information sharing and a single window compliance system that reduces fragmentation and strengthens oversight rather than duplicating it.

Fourth, and perhaps most pointedly, BAHLITA argued that enforcement should be focused on illicit trade, which it identified as the real threat to public health objectives, government revenue and fair competition for compliant businesses. The answer, the association said, is not more paperwork for legitimate traders but smarter enforcement, stronger traceability systems, better intelligence sharing and targeted action against illegal operators.

BAHLITA also pushed back against measuring the Bill’s success by the number of licenses issued or registers created. Instead, it argued success should be judged by whether the law actually reduces youth access to tobacco, strengthens compliance, combats illicit trade, protects government revenue and improves public health outcomes.

The association called on the National Assembly to avoid what it characterized as the Senate’s mistake, urging lawmakers to keep the process open, transparent and inclusive, with all affected stakeholders given a genuine chance to be heard. Good laws, BAHLITA maintained, are built through consultation, evidence and consensus, not exclusion.

Never miss a story 💜

Breaking news, real stories and money tips for Kenyan women, as they happen.

You may also like

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More