Kenya’s proposed changes to tobacco regulation are facing questions from both harm reduction experts and traders, as public participation on the Tobacco Control (Amendment) Bill of 2024 moves across the country.
In Meru, experts called for amendments to provisions they say could prevent the law from recognising differences between combustible and non-combustible nicotine products. In Kisumu, hospitality traders questioned whether some of the proposed restrictions, including raising the minimum smoking age to 21, can be implemented in practice.
The concerns point to a wider issue in the debate around the Bill. Protecting public health requires legislation that not only sets restrictions, but also takes account of how consumers and businesses will respond to them.
Harm reduction experts want clearer product distinctions.
Speaking during the public participation exercise in Meru on Friday, harm reduction experts argued that the Bill should distinguish between combustible tobacco products such as cigarettes and non-combustible products including nicotine vapes and pouches.
Dr Michael Kariuki, Secretary General of the Harm Reduction Society of Kenya, said treating the products in the same way could deny smokers who want to quit access to alternatives.
The experts also questioned why the amendment Bill does not include a definition of tobacco control. Kariuki said the definition should be incorporated into the law, noting that the Tobacco Control Act of 2007 was derived from the World Health Organization’s Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, which contains a definition of tobacco control.
Their concerns also extend to the proposed ban on flavours in tobacco products. According to Kariuki, flavoured nicotine products such as pouches can provide another option for smokers attempting to quit, making product variety an important part of the harm reduction conversation.
“We must adopt what we call the risk continuum in as far as tobacco is concerned,” he said, arguing that combustible and non-combustible products carry different levels of risk.
Kariuki also called for stronger implementation of existing laws to protect children and young people, rather than relying only on additional restrictions.
In Kisumu, traders question how new rules would work
The question of implementation was also central to discussions in Kisumu, where hospitality traders opposed a proposal to increase the minimum age for purchasing nicotine and tobacco products from 18 to 21.
The proposal emerged during a stakeholders’ engagement forum held in Nairobi earlier in the week. National Assembly Committee on Health Chairperson Dr James Nyikal said there had been broad agreement among stakeholders on raising the age.
But Dan Ouma, Chairperson of the Pubs, Entertainment and Restaurants Association of Kenya in Kisumu, said traders were concerned about how such a requirement would actually be enforced.
Ouma questioned whether consumers would be required to produce identification before purchasing the products and what mechanisms would be put in place to make the proposed age limit workable.
The traders also raised concerns about a proposal restricting the sale of tobacco and nicotine products within 100 metres of places with children. They argued that existing tobacco laws already provide for smoking zones, which they said address the issue.
Business licensing was another point of contention, with traders saying a requirement for tobacco-specific county licences could add to their operating costs because businesses already pay for single business permits.
Public participation now feeds into the next stage
The Bill, introduced by nominated Senator Catherine Mumma, has already passed the Senate and is now before the National Assembly Committee on Health. The committee has been engaging stakeholders and conducting public participation before preparing a report for consideration by MPs.
The sessions in Kisumu and Nanyuki on Saturday brought the public participation exercise to a close, with submissions from the counties now set to form part of the committee’s report.
What emerges from Meru and Kisumu is a debate that goes beyond whether tobacco regulation is necessary. There are also questions about whether the proposed rules distinguish between different products, give smokers alternatives if they want to quit, and can be enforced without creating additional difficulties for businesses.
Those questions will now sit with the National Assembly as it considers the submissions made during the public participation process.
Never miss a story 💜
Breaking news, real stories and money tips for Kenyan women, as they happen.