Absolutely. I’d build the entire article around that opening, keeping the activist edge but making sure every factual claim stays within the source material you provided.
There is a point at which regulation stops being about paperwork and starts eating into a small business owner’s livelihood.
Traders in Uasin Gishu County say the proposed Tobacco Control (Amendment) Bill risks reaching that point, particularly with a provision that would require businesses dealing in tobacco products to obtain a separate county licence despite already paying for a single business permit.
The concern was raised in Eldoret City during the second day of public participation on the Bill, where stakeholders called on Parliament to find a balance between protecting public health and protecting businesses and livelihoods.
The proposed licensing requirement would affect anyone manufacturing, distributing, storing, selling or otherwise dealing in tobacco products. Under the Bill, such businesses would be required to obtain a licence from the respective county executive committee member.
For traders, the problem is not simply having another document to display. It is the additional cost and bureaucracy that comes with it.
Businesses already pay for single business permits, and stakeholders argued that introducing a separate tobacco licence would amount to an additional financial burden for firms that are already operating under an existing licensing system.
For a small retailer, another government requirement can have a very different impact than it does on a large company. The cost still has to be paid, even when margins are tight and the business is trying to keep staff employed and remain open.
The licensing proposal was not the only provision questioned in Eldoret.
Stakeholders also raised concerns about a proposal that would prohibit the sale of tobacco products within a 100-metre radius of any place primarily serving people under the age of 18.
The Bill states that a person shall not sell a tobacco product within a radius of 100 metres from any place primarily serving people under 18 years.
Stakeholders argued that the restriction would be difficult to implement given the country’s current level of urbanisation, where businesses and institutions serving children can exist in close proximity.
For traders, the concern is that a rule that cannot be applied consistently could create uncertainty for businesses while doing little to address the underlying public health concern.
BAT Kenya Senior Regulatory Affairs Manager Billy Tsuma said the tobacco industry supports progressive legislation but argued that the proposed amendments should be evidence-based, consultative and practical to enforce.
He said stakeholders across the value chain had raised concerns about both county licensing and the proposed 100-metre restriction, urging the committee to consider the views emerging from the public participation process.
The call for practical enforcement was echoed by Sharlynne Chelang’at, a trader in Uasin Gishu County.
Rather than imposing the proposed 100-metre restriction, she called for stricter enforcement of the existing law prohibiting the sale of tobacco products to underage users, including penalties for those who break the law.
The debate is taking place as Parliament considers how Kenya should regulate new and emerging products in the tobacco industry, including nicotine pouches and vapes.
The Tobacco Control (Amendment) Bill was introduced in the Senate by nominated Senator Catherine Mumma and seeks to amend the Tobacco Control Act of 2007.
There is a legitimate public health question at the centre of that process. But there is also a legitimate economic question.
When Parliament creates a new requirement for a business, someone has to pay for it. When a rule restricts where a legal product can be sold, businesses have to work out whether they can still operate under it. And when enforcement becomes difficult, the law itself can become harder to apply.
That is why the public participation process is important. The people appearing before lawmakers are not only debating the principle of tobacco control. They are describing what the proposed rules could look like when they reach an actual shop, a counter and a business owner trying to make a living.
The National Assembly Committee on Health is undertaking public participation across seven counties. The exercise is scheduled to conclude in Kisumu and Laikipia before Parliament resumes sittings next Tuesday.
The task before lawmakers is now to weigh the health objectives of the Bill against the practical concerns being raised by the businesses expected to comply with it.
For the traders in Eldoret, the message is clear: regulation can protect public health, but it should not make legitimate businesses pay for rules that are difficult to implement.
Never miss a story 💜
Breaking news, real stories and money tips for Kenyan women, as they happen.